When I run my Managing Challenging Behaviour courses I talk about how even as adults we can be driven by desire (a need that can never be satisfied). While we may not tantrum like a two year old if we don’t get it, we can make a decision to go with something that is not essential (ie a new phone) over something more sensible (maybe paying the same amount of money off a debt, or saving it for emergencies)
I’m no different. I’ve got a Samsung Galaxy S2, which I adore and find is pretty much perfect for what I need as a phone, and a business tool. But with the Samsung Galaxy S3 coming out, I’m eying it up. I want it bad (well that OR the Galxy note, which I love too)
Do I physically, rationally need it? NO
Is my brain telling me I do? YES
I mean… it’s beautiful! And it has face recognition. And voice recognition. And, and, and….
If we as adults sometimes stuggle to openly identify from want and need, how much harder can it be for our children?
It is one of the reasons I’m still fairly careful about what level of technology my children personally own. My eleven year old is keen to take over my S2 once I get the S3 (because that IS going to happen
), but I feel it’s too much of a phone for an 11 year old. She doesn’t need a whizzbang phone. The only reason she has a phone at all is because she buses alone, and it’s a safety valve for me- not her.
Apparently four children in her class have iPhone 4s phones and many more have iPhone 4 phones. I find that fairly incredible. I’m unsure why they need those things.
If I give her that level of phone now, won’t I just be capturing her into the same cycle of need that so many adults themselves struggle with?
She, and my other children have open use to a laptop and a tablet, and all own ipods. Is a smart phone a must have for a tween? I think not.
I feel the same about the proposed changes regarding the facebook joining age. I’ve considered giving my children a private family page in the past, so they can communicate with their dad and other relatives with it. But my children are still learning the boundaries of what are good things to share online and what are not. They struggle to make those decisions. And I don’t have the time to micro manage every communication they have on facebook. So for now it’s still email and skype one on one with Dad and relatives.
I personally feel the age is low enough at 13 as it is. My children don’t need more reasons to be online. They need more reasons to connect with people face to face, to develop real life boundaries, to learn how to keep themselves safe offline, so that they can translate that to an online environment.
I’m more concerned with my children being entrusted with learning to walk to the shops by themselves, catch buses independently, arrange their own social lives, than spend more time using screens.
Am I alone in this?
And more importantly… if I’m not going to give the phone to my eleven year old, and it’s a perfectly good phone..
Who should have it?
Filed under: parenting | Tagged: facebook, samsung galaxy s3, smartphone, teenagers, tweens | 4 Comments »




